dotlit - The Online Journal of Creative Writing The Online Journal
of Creative Writing

 Edited by Donna Lee Brien (general), Philip Neilsen (poetry), and Axel Bruns (hypermedia and Webmaster) ISSN 1444-2817 
  ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... .....
 
Contents
Commissioned Works
Poetry
Prose
Creative Nonfiction
Hypermedia
Reviews
News
About
Archives
People
Contacts
Responses
Links

 

  ........... ........... ............          
   20 Nov. 2003

Deceptively Simplistic: the letter by Carl Steadman
Kathryn Mulheran

   
 
       
 
  the letter is a brief hypertextual meditation on issues of context and meaning in language and literature, in particular the 'letter' metaphor employed by Lacan and subsequently derided by Derrida. In a style reminiscent of a fairy tale, the piece follows the misadventures of a mysterious letter, with the circular 'storyline' serving as a clever form of expression for a rather difficult concept. the letter is a virtual illustration of Derrida's admission that meaning and language can never be closed off or translated with any finality. However, the nature of the concept driving the piece demands that the letter, like the literature it signifies, cannot be neatly framed into a uniform meaning, thus leaving it open to various interpretations.
  1  
  the letter is one of the abstract hypertextual works linked to Carl Steadman's main site, good evening, freedonia. Founder of the renowned suck.com and something of an Internet icon, Steadman's work apparently needs no introductions, as there are none provided for any of the sites. freedonia is, in fact, completely devoid of any supporting information other than the title/greeting 'good evening', a simple moon graphic and a few rows of links to Steadman's works. the letter is equally devoid of explanation-the reader is required to find their own way through the piece and attach their own meaning to the progression.
  2  
  The lexias within the letter are split into two uneven halves, the top half containing a black and white graphic that correlates to the single line of text below, while the links are contained within brackets in the lower half. The reader has three options for progressing through the lexias, advancing to the next page, skipping back to the previous page or jumping between lexias/pages. These are numbered from two to seventeen and book-ended by the 'title page' and a brief 'credits' section. When followed in logical progression, the lexias tell the tale of a letter addressed 'to whom it may concern'. From the pen of a Lacanian psychoanalyst, the letter is unearthed by a hen and abducted by a roving band of 'Lettrists', another group concerned with context-who see the words as empty letters to be spelled out with new meaning. The letter makes its way to the doorstep and subsequently the rubbish bin of a Derridean philosopher, then back around to its unearthing at the dump.
  3  
  This bizarre tale relates to a famous phrase coined by Lacan, that 'a letter always finds its address'. Lacan's structuralist and psychoanalytical readings of texts highlighted their context as of greatest importance. He believed that context creates desire and thus gives the text meaning and individual significance. Derrida not only criticised Lacan's methods and results, he endeavoured to illustrate that the antithesis was true in this case, that language, literature and psychology defy tidy categorisation and can have a myriad number of interpretations, thus 'a letter never finds its address."
  4  
  A great deal of thought has gone into the design of the letter and this is especially evident from Steadman's sources, listed in the 'credits' section. Illustrations used in the piece were scanned from 19th century children's books, while the manipulated text used in as background is credited as passages from Lacan, Derrida and Joyce's Finnegan's Wake. These graphics, while not essential, add to the effect of the piece and help to establish the somewhat 'fairy tale' atmosphere. The links are easy to follow, the chronological listing consolidates the circular motion and gives the reader an immediate and comforting sense of the size of the piece.
  5  
  The information contained within the lexias is brief and to the point and they lend themselves quite well to the fragmentation of the non-linear progression. The effect of the piece is heightened by several re-readings of the lexias and prior knowledge of the subject matter (however limited) is almost essential for the point to get across. the letter is a deceptively simplistic slice of philosophical contemplation stripped of confusing rhetoric and infused with a sense of fun. The hypertext structure allows the reader to explore different versions of the same story to highlight the importance of individual interpretation.   6  
Book Reviews
Back
1
  Forward
   
 
top index | author's bio | download this review © 2003